Dog Tail Cactus Vs Dragon Fruit
Cacti and succulents are currently quite popular. People love their interesting shapes and textures. Two unique cacti are the dragon fruit cactus and the dog tail cactus.
On the surface, they appear similar – both have thick, segmented stems lined with clusters of pads that resemble leaves. However, they have vital distinctions regarding flowers, fruit, optimal growing conditions, and more.
This article will dive deep into differentiating between these two desert dwellers. We’ll explore:
- Main differences in fruit production, flowers, stem shape
- Similarities in ideal soil type and climate preferences
- Specific care needs and cultivation requirements
This will help you tell apart and choose between these spiky plants for your garden. Let’s begin!
Looking for more information about Cactus Facts:
A Tale of Two Cacti: How Dragon Fruit and Dog Tail Differ
As mentioned earlier, at first glance, dragon fruit and dog tail cacti look almost identical – they both have flattened, segmented stems lined with clusters of leaf-like pads. However, some key differences set them apart, especially when producing fruit.
Fruit Production
The star distinction is that dragon fruit cacti actually grow edible fruit – and it’s delicious! The fruit is oval-shaped, about the size of your fist, with bright pink or yellow skin covered in scale-like ridges. Slice one open to find sweet, seed-speckled flesh as white as snow or vibrant magenta, depending on the variety.
Dog tail cacti, on the other hand, don’t yield any fruit at all. While they make up for it in unique charm, your taste buds won’t get any enjoyment out of dog tails.
Advantage: Dragon Fruit
Flower Power
Regarding flowers, both types of cacti produce showy blooms – but they look quite different.
Dragon fruit has enormous white flowers that unfurl after sunset, staying open all night. They can grow over a foot long! These fragrant, delicate flowers are fleeting, shriveling up in the daytime.
Dog tail cactus has smaller golden flowers that only open for one night. They don’t draw quite as much attention as dragon fruit flowers, but they have a subtle beauty.
Advantage: Dragon Fruit, for its tropical flower dynamos
Stem and Spine Differences
The bodies of these cacti also show some variation.
Dragon fruit stems are broad, flat, and clearly segmented into well-defined ridges. They look almost like stalks of leafy greens! The edges are lined with tiny hair-like spines.
Dog tail stems are more cylindrical and columnar without obvious ridges. They have noticeable clusters of large, firmer spines along each segment.
So dragon fruit cactus has flatter, distinctly segmented stems and tiny spines, while dog tail cactus has rounder stems with large spiny tufts.
Advantage: Toss up! One man’s trash is another man’s treasure
Growing Condition Preferences
While these desert plants share similarities, they differ slightly when it comes to their preferred climates.
Dragon fruit cactus thrives in warm, tropical environments above 50°F, ideally with 60-70% humidity. It can survive brief 32°F freezes.
Dog tail cactus is used in hot, arid deserts and is colder and hardier. It easily handles temps down to 20°F.
So, dragon fruit may be easier to grow if you live in a tropical or subtropical climate with balmy winters. Dog tail is better suited for drier heat and colder winters.
Advantage: It depends on your climate!
| Trait | Dragon Fruit Cactus | Dog Tail Cactus |
|---|---|---|
| Fruit Production | Produces red/pink/yellow oval fruit with sweet, edible flesh | It does not produce any fruit |
| Flowers | Large white flowers over 1 foot long that open at night | Smaller yellow-orange flowers that open one night |
| Stems | Broad, distinctly segmented, flatter with ridges | More rounded and columnar without clear ridges |
| Spines | Tiny hair-like spines along the edges | Noticeable large clusters of spines |
Climate | Prefers warm tropical environments above 50°F with some humidity | Withstands hot and arid deserts, cold hardy to 20°F |
Cousins in Arms: Shared Traits of Dragon Fruit and Dog Tail
While they have distinct differences, dragon fruit and dog tail cacti also share common ground regarding certain attributes. Let’s explore some of their key commonalities.
Both Are Nocturnal Bloomers
One similarity dragon fruit and dog tail cacti share is that they primarily bloom at night. This makes sense since they hail from hot desert climates – opening flowers during the cool of night helps conserve moisture and attract pollinators.
Their showy flowers unfurl after sunset, showing off beautiful displays in the moonlight. This makes them especially magical to behold on evenings when they decide to bloom. While dragon fruit’s enormous white blooms are more striking, dog tail’s petite yellow flowers are charming when they pop open.
Advantage: Nature lovers and night owls everywhere!
Succulent Desert Origins
It’s no coincidence that both cacti stem from arid, desert environments – likely the tropics for dragon fruit and deserts for dog tail.
Their fleshy, moisture-filled stems allow them to thrive with minimal water in these hot climates. They also have adapted growth patterns to hedge their bets, producing pads and shoots rapidly during rainy periods. These adaptations make both species nicely equipped for the driest desert gardens.
Advantage: Great choices for low-water landscaping!
Happy Growing in Containers
While in nature, you’ll find these cacti spreading extensively, you can easily tuck either one away in a container for your patio or windowsill. Their segmented stems adapt effortlessly to shallow pots, making dragon fruit or dog tail excellent container specimens.
Aim for a wide planter, not much deeper than the longest shoots. This gives adequate room for the stems to ramble horizontally without hitting drainage issues. Proper potting mix is still key – cactus blend enhanced with perlite provides fast drainage.
Advantage: They easily bring the desert to a compact space!
Similar Leaf and Stem Appearance
Upon initial glance, both cacti look so similar you might confuse young plants for each other. They produce the same flattened, oval green pads resembling leaves. Their pad clusters emerge from repetitively segmented vertical stems lined with areoles that can grow spines.
The difference lies in dragon fruit’s flatter, more defined stem ridges vs. dog tail’s rounded segments. But both structurally grow in comparable patterns.
Advantage: Easy to mix them up as young’uns!
While dragon fruit and dog tail cacti have unique merits, their shared background as desert dwellers unites them with common traits like nocturnal flowering, similar growth habits, and appreciation for hot, dry conditions. These bonds may make them perfect companions in an exotic garden miming their native habitats.
| Similarity | Description |
|---|---|
| Nocturnal Bloomers | Both have showy flowers that bloom at night |
| Desert Origins | Both are adapted to hot, arid desert environments. |
| Grow Well in Containers | Can flourish planted in pots/containers |
| Leaf/Pad Appearance | Have clusters of flattened, oval green pads that resemble leaves |
| Soil Needs | Require fast-draining soil with sand/perlite. |
| Sun Exposure | Prefer full sun – at least 6 hours a day. |
| Infrequent Watering | Only need water every 2-4 weeks once established. |
Cultivating Dragon Fruit and Dog Tail
Have you decided to add one of these desert beauties to your garden? Here’s the lowdown on caring for dragon fruit and dog tail cacti so your new plant thrives.
Choosing the Right Site
While they differ in ideal climates, both species need a warm, sunny spot. Dragon fruit likes humidity, while dog tail tolerates arid heat.
Sun Exposure
At least 6 hours of direct sun daily
Morning sun avoids intense afternoon heat
Temperatures
Dragon fruit likes consistent temps above 50°F
Dog tail handles down to 20°F
Humidity & Air Flow
Dragon fruit thrives around 60-70% humidity
Dog tail appreciates drier air
Aim for the best match to your climate. Shelter newly planted cacti until established.
Providing Proper Soil
These desert natives require fast-draining soil.
Ideal Mix
1 part potting mix to 1 part perlite or pumice
Can substitute cactus mix
Drainage
Needs excellent drainage
Add gravel, stones, etc to improve flow
Use containers with ample holes. Soil should dry rapidly after watering.
Watering Wisdom
Despite their desert heritage, young plants need more frequent watering to establish roots.
Seedlings
Water 1-2 times per week
Let soil partly dry between waterings
Mature Plants
Water every 2-3 weeks in summer
Once a month in winter
Always allow soil to fully dry before re-watering. Water less frequently in winter.
Encouraging Growth Through Care
Proper fertilization and trimming ensure that plants remain healthy and thriving.
Fertilizer: Use balanced cactus fertilizer at half-strength a few times during spring and summer.
Pruning: Cut back segments that become overly long and heavy to prevent breakage.
Dragon fruit and dog tail cacti are natural climbers. Set up supports as needed to guide growth.
Follow these tips tailored to your region, and your new succulent companion will flourish!
Frequently Asked Questions about These Cool Cacti
Are you still hungry for more insight into growing these desert mavericks? Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about crucial traits of dragon fruit and dog tail.
Can You Grow Dragon Fruit Indoors?
Dragon fruit grows best outside in the sun and heat but can also grow inside. A south-facing window should receive at least six hours of direct light daily for indoor plants. Supplement with a grow light. Give fertilizer every month and keep temperatures between 50 and 60 degrees Fahrenheit.
Which Climate Is Ideal for Raising Dog Tail Cacti?
Dog tail flourishes outdoors year-round in hot, arid climates like USDA Zones 9-11. Its extreme heat and cold tolerance allow it to sail through temperature extremes from 20°F to over 100°F. Shelter it until larger plants are established.
Does Dog Tail Cactus Produce Any Fruit?
Nope! Unlike its cousin dragon fruit, dog tail cactus doesn’t yield any edible fruit. It blooms cute yellow flowers, but they don’t develop into fruit later on. So don’t expect a harvest from a dog tail.
What Color Are Dragon Fruit Flowers?
Dragon fruit blooms are gorgeous white flowers, sometimes tinged with pink/purple. They open after sunset and wilt by late morning. Different species have differently shaped flowers – some with spiky petals, others rounded and bowl-shaped.
Is Dragon Fruit Cactus High Maintenance?
Not at all! Once established, dragon fruit requires little care beyond watering every 2-4 weeks and occasional fertilizing. It thrives on neglect and bounces back vigorously – perfect for busy gardeners. Just provide plenty of heat and sun exposure.
Final Verdict
While at first glance, dragon fruit and dog tail cacti seem nearly identical, they reveal some distinctive differences upon closer inspection. Dragon fruit’s exotic pink and yellow edible tropical fruit allows it to shine brightly – literally and figuratively. Dog tail cactus may lack flashy fruit but has understated charm through smaller pink and yellow flowers and furry, huggable-looking stems.
Though varied in some traits, their shared desert lineage unites them in similarities of care and cultivation as kings and queens of hot, sunny gardens. With the right environment, both will thrive in their new kingdom under your watchful eye of love and devotion. Now go forth and grow desert treasure!
If you found this article helpful, please share it with other plant owners
and consider following us on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest for more valuable plantation care information.
