Dog Tail Cactus Vs Rat Tail Cactus
Although trailing rat tail cacti are unusually beautiful plants, you may not be aware that there are two identical types—dog tail and rat tail cacti. Upon initial observation, they seem almost indistinguishable, featuring long, divided stems adorned with spiky clusters. Their dangling stems inspire the descriptive common names. But are they indeed the same plants?
No, there are a few key differences between these two popular succulents that enable gardeners to tell them apart confidently. From growth habits and water preferences to spikes and stem thickness, subtle variations set them apart.
To successfully grow healthy, vibrant rat tail cacti, you must understand precisely which one you have! Dig deeper now to discover the exact differences between dog tail cactus and rat tail cactus when it comes to visual characteristics, care needs, hardiness, and more.
Looking for more information about Cactus Facts:
Key Differences in Appearance and Growth
At a quick glance, dog tail cactus and rat tail cactus look astonishingly alike. Both have elongated, segmented stems lined with clusters of prickly spines. Their long, trailing stems inspire the common names that compare them to animal tails.
But when you take a closer look, subtle variations emerge between these two popular succulents. Let’s examine those key contrasts in stems, spines, and growing habits.
Stems – Skinny vs Stocky
The most obvious difference shows up in the stems. Dog tail cactus stems run on the lean side – they are typically pencil-thin, even spindly. Segments measure 1/2 inch to almost 2 inches. Rat tail cactus stems skew much thicker, ranging closer to 1 to 2 inches wide per section as they cascade downward.
Dog tail cactus stems also tend to run longer, with trailing runners extending around 3 feet or more whenever conditions allow. Rat tails usually stop around 2-foot lengths. These rangier stems inspired the name “dog tail,” similar to a hound’s lengthy, slender tail.
Spines – Spiky vs Bristly
Another prime distinction happens in the thorns department. Both feature groupings of spines emerging from fuzz at the stem segments. However, dog tail cactus spikes have a sharper, more dangerous look and feel. Needle-fine spikes measure at least 1⁄2-inch long, giving the plant its hazardous reputation.
Meanwhile, the rat tail cactus is armed with more densely packed, bristly spines at most 1/4 inch in length. They lend an almost fuzzy texture to the stems rather than posing any risk to human handlers. These soft bristles resemble the furry tail of a rat, accounting for its signature name.
Same, But Different
While linked by their signature elongated shapes, clear differences set dog tail and rat tail cacti apart when inspected up close. Once you train your eye to notice variations in stem width, spine texture, and growing direction, it becomes easy to tell these danglers apart confidently. Now, you can properly identify whichever you have, ensuring ideal care!
| Feature | Dog Tail Cactus | |
|---|---|---|
| Stems | Pencil-thin, spindly; 1⁄2″-2″ wide segments; around 3+ ft long | Thicker & stockier; 1″-2″ wide segments; around 2 ft long |
| Spines | Clusters of sharp, needle-fine spikes at least 1⁄2″ long | Densely packed, softer bristles around 1⁄4″ long |
| Growth Habit | Trailing vine – stems continue dangling downward | Initially trailing, later arching upward at the main stem |
Care and Cultivation Needs
Now that you can tell a dog tail from a rat tail, it’s time to demystify how to keep these adorable succulents happy at home. While their care needs overlap, a few key differences impact their ideal growing conditions. Let’s dig into the details!
Location
When it comes to real estate, tails value several amenities:
- Sunlight – Both demand full sun to look their best. Aim for a sheltered spot with maximum brightness.
- Space – These sprawling danglers need elbow room! Allow plenty of clearance to accommodate mature lengths of 2-3 feet.
- Support – Sturdy nearby objects provide stability for winding stems. A wall, railing, trellis, or potted neighbor plant works nicely.
Quenching Cactus Thirst
Here’s the big shocker when tending tails – cacti though they are, these rainforest natives relish moisture more than desert breeds. But exactly how often and how much to water does depend on the species:
- Dog tails need a drink almost constantly in active growth periods. Water whenever the top inch dries out.
- Rat tails tolerate brief droughts between waterings. Wait for the pots to dry first fully.
- Both thrive on humid air, making them great bathroom buddies! Regular misting keeps their skin hydrated.
Feeding & Fertilizing Fun
To support fast growth and flowing forms, tails require more nutrients than typical cacti:
- Feed monthly in spring and summer with a balanced liquid fertilizer diluted to half-strength.
- In winter, switch to low or no feeding so plants can rest.
- For pots, refresh the potting mix yearly in early spring to restore nutrition.
Primping & Pruning
Minimal grooming keeps stems growing long and lovely:
- Check for pests like spider mites or mealybugs. Wipe away any notices.
- Prune off dead or damaged stem sections to improve appearance.
- Trim excessively long tails if needed to keep the plant manageable. New offshoots will sprout below cuts.
Handling Hazardous Spines
Those wicked thorns demand caution! Dog tails especially sport tiny, hair-like spikes that detach at the slightest touch and embed painfully. When working around the stems:
- Wear sturdy gloves to avoid accidental pricks and skin irritation.
- Gently prop or tie dangling stems to access the pot without abrasions.
- Position plants away from high traffic zones to prevent bumps and injury. Handle gently!
Tailor Care to the Tail
While sharing basics like bright light and hanging room, clearly, dog tails and rat tails differ a bit in ideal conditions. Now that you know which cactus you have, you can fine-tune its care for amazing results!
Propagation Methods
Part of the fun of growing those fabulous trailing cacti comes from spreading happiness and obtaining even more! Luckily, both dog tail and rat tail varieties eagerly multiply when encouraged, quickly expanding your collection.
Let’s explore a few simple propagation methods to turn one fabulous tail into two…then three…then, who knows – you may end up with a whole pack of these puppies!
Snipping Stems
The easiest approach relies on the plant’s natural tendency to sprout roots all along its stems. Simply snip off a 6-8 inch section, allow the cut end to heal briefly, then stick it directly into loose, well-draining soil.
Within weeks, plump white roots emerge! Once established, the new plant can be left alone or detached and potted up separately.
Pro Tip: Take cuttings in spring or summer when tails are actively growing for best success.
Scooping Seeds
Mature tails bloom small, tube-shaped flowers in summer, later opening to release seeds. Pick a spent flower and gently shake out the tiny black pits onto a paper towel to dry.
In a few days, when the pits harden, sprinkle them atop a loose, damp seedling mix pressed firmly in a container. Cover the seeds lightly and set the container somewhere warm and bright.
Soon, you’ll spot sprouts! Thin crowded seedlings and transplant individual plants once they gain some size.
Grafting Gains
For rare varieties, gardeners often graft short stem pieces onto stocks of more vigorous species. This yields mature, blooming plants much faster than growing seedlings.
Grafted tails also tend to flower and fruit earlier and better than plants grown from cuttings or seeds. So consider grafting if you lust after a certain hard-to-find trailing tail!
Display and Companion Plantings
Beyond appreciating tails as solo trailing sculptures, it’s fun to incorporate them into lively companion plantings. Those dangling stems mingle beautifully with upright forms, spiky textures, and brighter blooms.
Fabricating Dazzling Displays
When crafting potted combos featuring tails as showstoppers, add height and contrast with the following:
- Spikes like agave or yucca
- Bold rosettes such as echeveria
- Vertical grandeur from flamboyant bromeliads
- Airy foam flowers or fluffy grasses
- Cluster several pots for a bountiful cactus garden!
Landing the Perfect Plant Neighbors
If dedicating a spot in your garden landscape to highlight tantalizing tails, surround stems with the following:
- Short, spreading sedums
- Brilliant lantana blooming nonstop
- Sculptural sotol or nolina
- Feathery stipa for movemen
This assortment of textures and colors lets trailing rat tails claim the spotlight while contributing supporting interest. Locate tails in front so their flowing forms get noticed!
Mix and Match for Intrigue
Have fun playing around with diverse plant companions near poised potted arrangements or poised in garden beds until you find winning combinations that show off those fabulous danglers to perfection. Such fabulous textures and fluid lines set rattling rat tails apart. Let them shine as the superstars they are meant to be!
Tail Top Frequently Asked Questions
Let’s wag through some frequent questions about growing those sensational trailing cacti:
Why the “Tail” Names?
It’s all about the long, dangling stems! Just like floppy dog tails and scaly rat tails, these cacti’s stems cascade downward the same way. The names quickly convey the key trailing habit.
How Fast And Large Do They Grow?
Expect 12 or more inches of new growth per year. Well cared for dog tails may reach 6 feet long by maturity. Rat tails typically max out around 3 feet. The length depends partly on the provided support for all that length!
What’s Better – Dog Tail Or Rat Tail Cactus?
Both make fabulous houseplants! Beginners might find rat tails easier thanks to their less demanding water needs and softer spines. But dog tail appeals to fans of unique plants and bold textures. Try one or both!
Can I Grow Them Indoors?
You sure can! Their tropical heritage adapts well to interiors. Provide ample sunlight, room for expansion, humidity through misting, and an occasional summer vacation outdoors—pot up pups for gifting and trade among fellow houseplant enthusiasts.
Is Rat Tail Cactus Poisonous?
Nope, both species are non-toxic to curious pets who might nibble or brush against dangling stems. But those tiny, hair-like needles shed easily from dog tails, potentially causing mouth or skin irritation. Best to display out of temptation’s reach!
Parting Thoughts
While dog tail and rat tail cacti share wildly curling cascades, they aren’t carbon copies. Once aware of differences in stem width, spine sharpness, and growing habits, distinguishing between them becomes easy for even novice succulent fans.
Hopefully, this guide helped you determine precisely which variety you have. Armed with that knowledge, you can now tailor conditions to your plant’s particular needs and watch it thrive, trailing gracefully for years of enjoyment. As beloved houseplants or distinctive garden accents, fabulous hanging tails always make a statement!
If you found this article helpful, please share it with other plant owners
and consider following us on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest for more valuable plantation care information.
